I’ve read all of these books. I agree that Evelyn Hugo belongs at #1. But for me, (and this is JMO and not at all to argue against your rankings) Malibu Rising was an absolute dud: I was especially annoyed at the clickbait way she handled the “wildfire” aspect. Daisy Jones would be #2 and Carrie Soto #3. To me, Reid at her best when she’s writing “famous” characters. I was disappointed when she announced she was abandoning that angle. Her “everyday” characters just don’t do it for me. I enjoyed reading your opinions on these novels.